0% Complete
Minds on

MINDS ON

 Vocabulary 301

Rhetoric: The art of effective or persuasive speaking or writing, especially the use of figures of speech and other compositional techniques.
This is a black and white profile head shot of a young boy shouting into an old style microphone.
What grinds your gears?

Long before the written word, people used sophisticated and nuanced (definition: A subtle distinction or variation, typically planned.) oral communication skills to communicate their passions and positions to audiences.  Sometimes these audiences were receptive, and other times they were not.  An effective oral communicator knows that it's important to understand the audience - their demographic (definition:The statistical characteristics of human populations, such as age, gender, religion or income, etc.), as well as their ideology (definition:The set of ideas and beliefs of a group or political party.) - before saying a single word.  

While this might sound manipulative, some linguists argue that language's main purpose is to convince others.  For example, think about a time when you wanted something that you needed someone else's help to get.  Perhaps it was a new toy, or help with a tedious task, or support to ask someone out, or a curfew extension.  Odds are, you put some thought into how you would approach that person before you asked for anything.  In fact, you may have even considered what words, tone, time, place and even body language you would use to convince this person to agree.  After all, if you are asking for an extension on your curfew, it's likely you'll get a more positive answer if you use words that suggest reassurance and safety, and if you maintain a clear, non-arrogant tone. A positive answer will also be more likely if you ask during a time and place where the person potentially agreeing isn't stressed or in a bad mood, and if you use body language that indicates that you feel confident and involved in the discussion.  Alternately, think about applying for a job.  Would you swear and use slang, sound bored, interrupt a meeting and/or slump back in a chair?  Probably not (and you probably wouldn't get the job if you did!).  

Determining how, why and when to say something is an art, and this art form's name is rhetoric.  So, while it may carry a negative connotation, in reality, rhetoric is a series of tools that skilled oral communicators use to convey their message effectively.  While there are many different elements to rhetoric, its three main components are below.

Ethos: the presenter's credibility or authority, in the eyes of the target audience.

Pathos: the use of emotion to influence this audience.

Logos: the use reason and logic to create a persuasive argument for this audience.

Now that you've been introduced to rhetoric's main components, it’s time to determine your ability to detect ethos, pathos, and logos by completing the following interactive.

DetectingBias

Long Description

 

Now that you've had a chance to hone your skills, it's time to learn how to use rhetoric to get what you want...

 

One way of using rhetoric to get what you want is by ranting.(definition:To speak in an emotionally charged manner for a short amount of time.) While rants can be loud, aggressive and illogical, when developed and delivered appropriately, they have the power to create large-scale change.  Canadian comedian Rick Mercer is famous for using his rants to question, critique and influence audiences' perceptions about subjects ranging from snow days, to young voters, to LGTBQ2I rights, to today's students. 

This is the Portfolio icon. Rhetorical Techniques

To understand how Rick Mercer uses rhetoric in his rants, view the following rant from his Rick Mercer Report television show.  As you watch it, make entries in your Notebook about how he uses ethos, logos and pathos, as well as other rhetorical techniques such as diction,(definition: The formal term for purposefully selecting words.) tone, body language and humour, as well as camera angles and settings.  You'll likely notice many literary devices being used as well, especially hyperbole, metaphors, similes and allusions.  This is because literary devices can also be used as rhetorical devices.

This is the discussion icon. Reviewing Rick's Rants

After viewing Rick's rant, indentify whether you believed it was effective and why.  Make sure that you explicitly mention the different ways he used rhetoric to convey his message to his audience.  

Resources

To learn more about how you can use rhetorical tools to capture attention and convince audiences, check out the following websites.
  1. A Handbook of Rhetorical Devices provides many comprehensive device definitions and examples, along with a self-test on the final page.

  2. 50 Rhetorical Devices for Rational Writing lists 50 rhetorical devices, along with definitions and examples.

  3. Literary Devices: Rhetoric lists many rhetorical devices as a subsection of their use as literary devices.

  4. Rhetorical Devices and How To Use Them provides both devices’ definitions and examples, as well as advice on how to use them effectively.

Action.

ACTION

This is the Portfolio icon. Diction

Before you begin writing your own performance pieces, it’s important to ensure that you use the best word or phrase to express your ideas. Complete the following interactive activity for a chance to expand your lexicon and learn how different diction affects the author's intention and audience's appreciation. There are three selections to complete. After completing each one, take a screenshot of your paragraph as compared to the original paragraph.  Keep these screenshots in your Notebook.

Diction

 
 

This is the dropbox icon. Rant Away!

It's time to put your new-found ranting skills into practice.  You can rant on anything you'd like, other than a non-public person (e.g., an enemy at school, an annoying sibling, a teacher, etc).  Write a rant that is between one to two minutes in length.  It should contain ethos, logos and pathos, as well as other rhetorical devices.  Once you are finished writing (alternately, you can use a speech-to-text program), annotate your rant by indicating one example of ethos, logos and pathos, as well as a brief description explaining how each example makes your rant effective.

This is an image of a painting showing the Roman orator Cicero speaking to the Roman Senate.
Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears...

Public speaking has long been an avenue for expressing and sharing ideas.  Indeed, one of the reasons that democracy exists is that it usually guarantees people the right to express their ideas without immediate, negative consequences.  Sadly, this noble ideal is not always practiced in real life.  However, whether at a rally, in a courtroom, or simply conversing with your friends, public speaking enables people to express themselves.  Indeed, when it's effective, it can encourage change.  There are many different reasons to give a speech, including to be entertaining, persuasive, supportive and explanatory.  Depending on your speech's purpose, it can dramatically affect not only the content, but also its delivery.

When developing and delivering a speech, you must consider important elements such as your rhetorical choices, your audience, your message and your call-to-action.(definition:This is a statement designed to get an immediate response from the person reading or hearing it.) In addition, you must ensure it is thoroughly researched and accurate.  This doesn't mean that you aren't allowed to have opinions: instead, it means that you should recognize the difference between facts and opinions to ensure your speech is both effective and accurate.

To ensure you are able to tell the difference between facts and opinions, complete the following interactive.

FactOrOpinion

 

This is the tips icon. Did You Know?

Though Wikipedia is an excellent resource, especially in the early stages of research, that doesn't mean that it's always accurate.  In fact, Wikipedia itself warns you of that very fact.  Read this article, Wikipedia: General disclaimer from Wikipedia. (Original article)

If you want to view any links in this pdf, right click and select "Open Link in New Tab" to avoid leaving this page. (View the original article.)

 
This is a a head shot of a man who is shouting angrily and pointing at the camera.
Don't misquote me!

It's important to conduct research that is vetted. (definition: Making a careful and critical examination of someone or something using reliable, often multiple, sources.) For example, you may have heard of the 7%-38%-55% rule for communication.  Essentially, this is a misinterpretation of psychology professor Albert Mehrabian's Decoding of Inconsistent Communications paper where people have wrongly presumed that only 7% of what people understand comes from the actual words said (with 38% being tone and 55% being body language).  Mehrabian clarifies his intention when he says, "Unless a communicator is talking about their feelings or attitudes, these equations are not applicable."  While it may be appealing to be able to tie communication to percentages, convenience doesn't make something true.

This is the Portfolio icon. Secrets to Great Public Speaking

As you prepare to develop and deliver your own speech, take a moment to view Chris Anderson's TED talk TED's Secret to Great Public Speaking.  Record Anderson's strategies in your Notebook for later use.

 

 Sidequest: Vocal Strategies

Similar to any skills, effective oral communication requires practice, perseverance (definition: Continuing to do something despite difficulty or delay in achieving success.) and patience.  Fortunately, there are also numerous resources available to help you improve.  If you want to learn more about complex vocal strategies, then view Julian Treasure's TED Talk about speaking so that people want to listen.

 

Now that you've learned more ways to use your voice, put them into practice by recording yourself using these strategies.  Do you notice a difference?  Try it with your friends or family and see if they notice a difference, as well!

This is the dropbox icon. Successful Speeches

There are many ways to deliver a successful speech.  To give you some insight into what makes a speech successful, you will seek and share by finding an example of a successful speech online.  The speech must be available in an oral or visual medium.  Afte you have chosen your speech, answer the following prompts in the medium of your choice.  If you need assistance to find exemplary speeches, review the resources below these prompts.

  1. Summarize the speech in three to five sentences.
  2. Provide a brief biography of the speaker.  What makes this individual an authority on their chosen topic or focus?
  3. State the speaker's thesis (or call-to-action) in your own words.
  4. Identify how your chosen speech uses at least one of the strategies Chris Anderson mentioned in his TED Talk above.
  5. Who was the intended audience?  How do you know?
  6. Identify two arguments the speaker gives to support their thesis.  Are they effective?  If so, why?  If not, why not?
  7. Explain, concisely, how the introduction and conclusion is - or, is not - effective. 
  8. Find and copy an example for each of ethos, logos and pathos.  Are they used effectively?  If so, how so?  If not, why not?
  9. Find, copy, and identify three different rhetorical devices used and explain how each does or does not develop the speaker's thesis. 
  10. How does the speaker use their voice in this speech?  Is it effective or not?  Provide direct evidence for your arguments.
  11. If you were to give this speech, what would you change to make it more effective?  Explain your answer.
  12. Provide an MLA formatted Works Cited page.

Resources

  1. 55 Speeches by Influential People of the 21st Century provides a video summary of excellent speeches ranging from Sir Ken Robinson to Steve Jobs.
  2. 25 Powerful Commencement Speeches by Famous Women provides both a summary and full transcript of these powerful speeches.
  3. American Rhetoric is a website that provides hundreds of classical and contemporary American speeches, most with a transcript and accompanying oral or visual performances.
  4. 25 iconic speeches you’ll want to watch on repeat is a blog post that provides YouTube links to many important speeches.
Consolidation

CONSOLIDATION

This is the dropbox icon. Personally Speaking

Now that you've learned what makes a speech successful, it's time to write (not deliver, you'll be doing that later on) your own. Your speech can be on any topic of your choice. Some strategies for the development of written ideas include: rapid writing, using a graphic organizer, ranking potential topics and asking questions.  If you need help to come up with a topic, there are resources below to assist you.  Make sure you review the following checklist before you finalize your speech.

  Checklist Items
My written speech contains ethos, logos and pathos.
My written speech is four to six minutes in length.
My written speech contains rhetorical devices.
My written speech has a clear call-to-action.
My speech has a distinct voice.
My speech engages the audience through the use of diction (evocative words and phrases).
My speech has complete sentences.
My speech is clearly communicated as a result of my accurate use of grammar.
My speech incorporates a variety of sentence structures and lengths.
My speech includes logical transitions between ideas.

Resources

  1. Public Speaking Speech Topics and Ideas lists hundreds of topics, both persuasive and informational.
  2. 100 Good Persuasive Speech Topics provides one-hundred prompts.
  3. Easy Persuasive Speech Topics lists hundreds of questions to help generate ideas and positions.

This is the discussion icon. Rant Away!

Time to go back to the rant you wrote earlier. Now you will record yourself performing your rant! This means you must revise your rant prior to your performance.

You can record yourself orally or via video.  

test text.